Peter is first seen with Judy moving in Alan's empty house with their Aunt Nora after his parents died in a skiing accident. He and Judy discovered "Jumanji" in the attic and he and Judy began playing the game as Wasps and Monkeys appear. He meets Alan Parrish after Alan is released out of the game. He comforts Alan for the loss of his parents. He agrees to let Alan and Sarah continue playing the game as a vine drags him and he is saved by Alan.
After Van Pelt is released and a stampede wrecks the house, Peter transforms into a monkey while trying to cheat. He was saved by Sarah and Judy from being crushed by an elephant destroying a car. Peter manages to stop Van Pelt by using an air tank and a canoe to push Van Pelt in order to save the game. After Alan shows up after being taken away by a police officer (his old friend from his dad's shoe factory), the four continued to play as a monsoon floods the house and two crocodiles appear and large spiders. He saves Judy, Alan and Sarah by using Alan's dad's axe and he comforts Judy. By the end of the film, he is seen with Judy and his parents meeting Alan and Sarah, who convince Peter and Judy's parents to start work for the shoe company and canceling their skiing holiday to Canada, thus preventing their death in the previous timeline.
- Peter and Judy are the only characters from the original book to appear in the film adaptation.